Natural Butterscotch Extract

This natural butterscotch extract delivers a concentrated sweet, buttery flavor that blends easily into batters, sauces, and drinks. It has a candy-like butterscotch taste similar to toffee, with enough intensity that a small amount flavors a full batch of baked goods. The flavor stays strong in both baked and frozen desserts. Use it to add butterscotch character to cakes, cookies, ice cream, coffee, syrups, and homemade sauces.

  • Gluten-free
Size
Regular price $12.95

Flavor Profile

Primary flavor is sweet, buttery butterscotch. Secondary notes of brown sugar, vanilla, and cream give it a smooth, toffee-like depth.

How To Use

Start with 1 teaspoon to flavor about 3 cups of baking mix, then adjust to taste. Stir into cake batters, frostings, syrups, sauces, or hot drinks; it also works well alongside cinnamon, cloves, vanilla, or maple in baked goods.

FAQ

What does butterscotch extract taste like?
Butterscotch extract tastes sweet and buttery, with notes of brown sugar, vanilla, and cream. It is similar to toffee and can also stand in for caramel-style flavors in desserts.

How much butterscotch extract should I use in baking?
About 1 teaspoon is enough to flavor 3 cups of baking mix. Because it is concentrated, start small and increase if you want a stronger butterscotch flavor.

Can I use butterscotch extract instead of caramel or toffee extract?
Yes. Butterscotch extract has a similar sweet, brown sugar and butter flavor, so it works well as a substitute for caramel or toffee extracts in most baking and dessert recipes.

Free Shipping

Spend $60 or more and we’ll ship your spices for free.

Satisfaction Guarantee 

Not in love with a spice? We’ll replace it with one you’ll enjoy.

Local Pickup

Shop online and pick up in-store. No waiting, no shipping fees!

Freshness & Quality

Crafted in CO, our small-batch spices are always full of flavor.